VA Higher-Level Review: preparing your issue list

How to prepare an issue list for a VA Higher-Level Review, including the no-new-evidence rule, informal conference tips, and what to check before filing.

A laptop and notebook on a desk beside a window
Photo: Sami Abdullah ยท Pexels License. Existing approved local photograph; displayed with a responsive crop.

Quick answer

A VA Higher-Level Review examines the existing record without new evidence. List the decisions and issues you want reviewed, identify the errors you believe occurred and decide whether to request the optional informal conference.

A Higher-Level Review asks a more senior VA reviewer to look again at a decision you disagree with. The reviewer checks whether the earlier decision contains an error or whether a different opinion changes the outcome. The defining feature is that you cannot submit new evidence with this review, so your preparation centers on the record VA already has.

That constraint shapes everything about how you build your issue list. Instead of gathering new records, you identify exactly which findings you dispute, why the existing file supports your position, and what you want the reviewer to reconsider. This guide walks through the practical steps, the informal conference, and the questions worth answering before you file.

What a Higher-Level Review actually does

A Higher-Level Review is one of the decision review options under the Appeals Modernization Act. You or your accredited representative request that a higher-level reviewer examine the decision and determine whether an error or a difference of opinion changes it. The reviewer generally decides based on the evidence already in the file.

The review has eligibility conditions. You must request it within one year of the decision on your initial claim or Supplemental Claim, counting from the date on your decision letter. You must have no new evidence to submit, and your claim cannot be a contested claim. You also cannot request a Higher-Level Review after a previous Higher-Level Review or Board Appeal on the same issue.

If you do have new and relevant evidence, a Supplemental Claim or Board Appeal is the route designed for that material. Choosing between review options is a personal decision, and an accredited representative can help you weigh them without pushing you toward one lane.

Program reference: Higher-Level Reviews | Veterans Affairs.

Building your issue list before you file

Start with the decision letter itself. Read the findings one at a time and mark the specific issues you disagree with rather than the decision as a whole. A clear issue list is easier for a reviewer to work through than a broad objection.

For each issue, note the decision date and the reason you believe the finding is wrong. Reasons tend to fall into a few shapes: a factual detail was misread, a regulation was applied incorrectly, or the evidence in the file was weighed in a way you think was mistaken. Write these in plain language you can explain aloud.

Keep every issue within the same benefit type. The form does not let you select multiple benefit types at once, so separate forms are needed for separate benefit types. If you are unsure which benefit type applies, your decision letter will tell you.

  • Read the decision letter and highlight each disputed finding separately.
  • Record the decision date next to every issue you plan to raise.
  • Write one or two sentences per issue explaining the error you see.
  • Confirm all listed issues belong to a single benefit type.
  • Check that no earlier Higher-Level Review or Board Appeal covered the same issue.

Filing the request

For disability compensation claims, VA accepts online Higher-Level Review requests. Other claim types go by mail, in person at a VA regional office for claims not related to healthcare benefits, or through an accredited attorney, claims agent, or Veterans Service Organization representative. The form is VA Form 20-0996, Decision Review Request: Higher-Level Review.

Mailing addresses differ by benefit type, so match your envelope to the benefit you selected on the form. For any benefit not listed in the instructions, check your decision letter for submission guidance. An accredited representative can help you complete the form if any section is unclear.

Preparing for an informal conference

An informal conference is an optional call with the higher-level reviewer assigned to your case. It is not a formal hearing, and you still cannot submit new evidence during it. Its purpose is to let you or your representative point out the factual or legal errors you identified.

You request the conference on the form, either during the online steps for disability compensation or at the designated item on the PDF version. The reviewer will call you or your representative to schedule a time, and may also send a scheduling link by email or text. The reviewer makes two attempts to reach you; if those fail, the case is decided without the conference.

Only one informal conference is allowed per Higher-Level Review, and asking for one may extend how long the decision takes. Some people instead attach a written statement describing the errors, which can support a faster decision. If you have a representative, coordinate scheduling with them and have your notes ready before the call.

What happens after you file

VA generally decides based on the existing evidence. You do not need to act unless VA sends a letter asking for more information. Sometimes the reviewer finds a duty-to-assist error, meaning VA did not help gather all the evidence needed for the claim; VA then lists the steps to fix it, gathers the missing evidence, and decides on that basis. If an exam is scheduled, attend it.

Possible outcomes include the reviewer finding the earlier decision correct, deciding in your favor, or identifying a duty-to-assist error and correcting it. Either way, you receive a new decision letter. VA's stated goal for completing a Higher-Level Review unrelated to healthcare benefits is an average of about 125 days, though an informal conference can lengthen that.

If you disagree with the result, you can request a Board Appeal for a Veterans Law Judge to review the case, or file a Supplemental Claim if you have new and relevant evidence. Here is a hypothetical planning example: a veteran disputes two findings in one decision and writes a short paragraph on each, then decides whether a written statement or a conference better fits their schedule. That is planning, not a prediction of any outcome.

Pre-filing checklist for your issue list

  • Read the full decision letter and separate each finding you dispute.
  • Write the decision date beside every issue on your list.
  • Draft a brief explanation of the error for each issue in plain language.
  • Verify all issues fall under one benefit type and plan separate forms if not.
  • Confirm you have no new evidence you want considered, since this review excludes it.
  • Decide whether to request an informal conference or attach a written statement.
  • If represented, share your issue list with your representative before filing.

Common questions

Can I add new medical records to a Higher-Level Review?

No. A Higher-Level Review does not consider new evidence. If you have new and relevant evidence, a Supplemental Claim or Board Appeal is the appropriate option to explore.

What happens if I miss the informal conference call?

The reviewer makes two attempts to reach you or your representative. If contact is not made after those attempts, the reviewer proceeds to decide the case without the conference.

Official sources

Source check: November 13, 2026. How these guides are maintained.